Coalition for the International Criminal Court
Follow Us: Facebook Twitter
CICCCourtCoalitionCoalitionDocumentsPressDonation
Browse by Region
map Americas Africa Asia and Pacific Europe Middle East and North Africa
Third Election - 2007
Results of Election of ICC Judges

On Friday, 30 December 2007, during the first round of elections for ICC judges at the Sixth Session of the Assembly of States Parties to the Rome Statute of the ICC at UN headquarters in New York, two new ICC judges were elected. They are Fumiko Saiga of Japan and Bruno Cotte of France.

On Monday, 3 December 2007, during the fourth round of elections for ICC
judges at the 6th session of the Assembly of States Parties to the Rome
Statute of the ICC at the UN headquarters in New York, Judge Daniel David Nsereko of Uganda was elected and thereby completed the ICC bench.

These judges will fill three vacancies arising from the resignations of Judges Maureen Harding Clark (Ireland), Karl T. Hudson-Phillips (Trinidad and Tobago), and Claude Jorda (France). For this election, at least two judges were required to be "list A" candidates (those wtih criminal law experience).

After the election of all three judges, Judge Saiga was selected by lot to
serve the remaining 1-2 years of Judge Jorda’s term (2009) and will be
eligible for re-election for an additional 9-year term. The two other judges, Judge Cotte and Judge Nsereko will serve only the remaining 3-4 years of Judges Clark’s and Hudson-Phillips’ terms, both who were serving nine-year terms expiring in
2012.

Below are detailed results from the four rounds.

Results of first round

SAIGA, Fumiko of Japan with 82 votes

COTTE, Bruno of France with 79 votes

NSEREKO, Daniel David of Uganda with 54 votes

PERMANAND, Jean Angela of Trinidad and Tobago with 50 votes

DIXON, Graciela of Panama with 45

Total votes: 105

Results of second round

NSEREKO, Daniel David of Uganda with 53 votes

PERMANAND, Jean Angela of Trinidad and Tobago with 26 votes

DIXON, Graciela of Panama with 25 votes

Total votes: 105

One invalid vote

69 votes were required to elect the third judge and no candidate reached this target. A third round was therefore held on Monday 3 December 2007.

Results of third round

NSEREKO, Daniel David of Uganda with 60 votes

PERMANAND, Jean Angela of Trinidad and Tobago with 21 votes

DIXON, Graciela of Panama with 21 votes

Total votes: 102

Hence, no ICC judge was elected in the third round as no candidate received a two-third majority of the 102 States Parties present and voting: 68 votes.

Following the third round, Trinidad and Tobago announced the withdrawal of
Justice Permanand's candidacy.

Results of fouth round

NSEREKO, Daniel David of Uganda with 74 votes

DIXON, Graciela of Panama with 28 votes

Total votes: 102

Nominations

The nomination period closed on 24 August 2007. By the closing date, the ASP Secretariat had received 6 nominations. The nomination of Mr. Sunday Akinola Akintan of Nigeria was subsequently withdrawn on 20 September 2007.

The following five candidates were nominated for the third election of judges:


CandidateNationalityList A/BGender

NSEREKO, Daniel David Ntanda

Uganda

List A

Male

PERMANAND, Jean Angela

Trinidad and Tobago

List A

Female

SAIGA, Fumiko

Japan

List B

Female

COTTE, Bruno

France

List A

Male

DIXON, Graciela

Panama

List A

Female