![]() |
|
|
Browse by Region
|
Darfur: Sudan To Prosecute Kushayb; Kushayb Denies Charges; Bashir
06 Mar 2007
Dear All,
Please find below a digest (2 March 2007) of continued media coverage on the ICC Prosecutor's request for summonses for Ahmad Muhammad Harun and Ali Muhammad Ali Abdal-Rahman. A. SUDAN ANNOUNCES ITS OWN PROSECUTION OF KUSHAYB: Sudan has announced that it will try three Sudanese citizens, including one of the ICC suspects, Muhammad Ali Abdal-Rahman, also known as Ali Kushayb. Some reports have characterized this effort as "an attempt to pre-empt" the ICC. An Agence France Presse article reporting on this development also highlights domestic division over the ICC's announcement including possibly within President Bashir's own National Congress Party as well as remarks by former UN Envoy to Sudan Jan Pronk. B. KUSHAYB DENIES ICC CHARGES: Ali Kushayb has denied the ICC's charges. "We did not kill any innocent people and we did not cause the displacement of any people," Kushayb was quoted as saying in the pro-Arab, pro-Islamist Al Intibaha newspaper. C. PRESIDENT BASHIR REITERATES REJECTION OF ICC JURISDICTION: President Omar al-Bashir has reiterated that "(The) Sudanese judiciary is honest and qualified to try any Sudanese". "The government will not hand over any citizen for trial outside the country," added al-Bashir. D. SUDANESE REACTIONS WELCOMING ICC ANNOUNCEMENT (1) An article in the Times (London) highlights several victims' reactions to the ICC's announcement: "We were jubilant when we heard the news," said one victim, while another stated, "Justice is good. I would like that." (2) In an interview with Reuters, opposition figure Hassan al-Turabi said the government should cooperate with the ICC, noting, "There is no justice here. Justice has to come from international courts, from outside." (3) The opposition National Ummah Party has urged all the sides in the Darfur conflict and in particular the government, to cooperate with the ICC. (4) The opposition Communist Party has urged the government to hand over the suspects to the ICC. E. SUDANESE REJECTIONS OF ICC ALLEGATIONS AND JURISDICTION (1) A majority of respondents to a poll conducted by Al-Jazeera.net have reportedly expressed support for Sudan's position not to transfer any citizens to the ICC. (2) The Ta'aysha tribe of ICC suspect Ali Kushayb has rejected the possibility of handing him over to the ICC. (3) Presidential assistant and deputy leader of the rulin] National Congress Party, Dr Nafi Ali Nafi has criticized those who have announced their support of the ICC. (4) The Parliamentary Group of North Kordofan State has described the ICC announcement as illegal and incorrect. (5) The Darfur Lawyers Association has denounced the ICC allegations. (6) During a symposium on "The Decision of ICC between the Law and Politics," Legal Expert Dr. Khalid Hussein Mohamed qualified the ICC announcement as a political decision. (7) Head of Legislation and Legal Affairs Committee at the Council of States Dr. Ismail Al-Haj Musa stated that Sudan would 'reactivate' complementarity. F. EUROPEAN UNION COUNCIL CONCLUSIONS: The European Union, in its Council Conclusion on Darfur, has welcomed the Prosecutor's announcement and urged the Sudanese government to cooperate. G. OTHER INTERNATIONAL REACTIONS: (1) Egyptian President Husni Mubarak was briefed by a Sudanese representative on developments in Sudan. With regards to the ICC, the adviser said that the Sudanese government formed committees to find means to face this development. (2) The Malaysian Foreign Minister, Sayed Hamid Al-Bar, has described the Prosecutor's decision as unjustifiable, political and illegal. (3) SUNA reports on reactions by those "concerned with the Sudanese situation" living in the United Kingdom. Please take note of the Coalition's policy on situations before the ICC (below), which explicitly states that the CICC will NOT take a position on potential or pending situations before the Court. The Coalition, however, will continue to provide the most up-to-date information about the ICC. Warm Regards, Esti Tambay Information and Analysis Officer Coalition for the International Criminal Court **************************************************** A. SUDAN ANNOUNCES ITS OWN PROSECUTION OF KUSHAYB 1. Associated Press, "Sudan to try three people on crimes relating to Darfur crisis," 6 March 2007 http://www.iht.com/articles/ap/2007/03/06/africa/AF-GEN-Sudan-Darfur.php "Sudan said Tuesday it will try three Sudanese on charges of crimes relating to the Darfur crisis in what appeared to be an attempt to pre-empt and the International Criminal Court's investigation into accusations of crimes against humanity in the war-torn region. Details about the charges or alleged crimes were not available, but Sudan's official news agency, SUNA, reported that the trial would start Wednesday in the western Darfur capital of El-Geneina. Among the three was Ali Mohammed Ali Abd-al-Rahman, also known as Ali Kushayb, a member of Sudan's security forces who is one of two suspects sought by the ICC over accusations of war crimes and crimes against humanity. [...] Even though the ICC cannot prosecute individuals already on trial for the same crime in their own country, chief ICC prosecutor Luis Moreno-Ocampo said that Khartoum's investigation of Kushayb does not "encompass the same conduct that is the subject of the case now before the Court (ICC)." The ICC case alleges Harun and Kushayb worked "together to commit alleged crimes against humanity and war crimes," Moreno-Ocampo told The Associated Press. However, he indicated Sudan and the two Sudanese suspects may challenge ICC's jurisdiction but that this would be for the judges to rule on. [...] The Sudanese government had told the ICC, which is based in The Hague, Netherlands, that Kushayb was arrested last November and was in custody pending an investigation into five attacks in which hundreds of people were killed. It was not immediately known if the trial set to start Wednesday in Darfur was related to that investigation. [...] Interior Minister Zubair Bashir Taha told the Sudan Media Center on Tuesday that the accusations against Harun were "unfounded and seek to undermine security and stability in the country." [...]" 2. Agence France Presse, Mohammed Ali Saeed, "Sudan scrambles to deflect pressure over Darfur war crimes," 6 March 2007 (link not available) "Sudan is seeking to take the lead and drag Darfur war crimes suspects in front of its own courts, despite divisions at home and world pressure to hand them over to an international court. A special court in West Darfur is due to open proceedings Wednesday against three security officials suspected of murdering civilians and burning down their villages. "Three suspects will appear in front of the special criminal court in Geneina. Trial proceedings will start on Wednesday," the official SUNA news agency reported. The move was announced late Monday, a week after Khartoum came under renewed pressure when the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague for the first time named suspected Darfur war criminals. [...] But the ICC's offensive against the Sudanese regime -- which stands accused of genocide by Washington and of being responsible for the world's worst ongoing humanitarian crisis -- has left domestic political forces divided. Diverging views within the unity cabinet itself were again highlighted last week when Salva Kiir, the southern rebel leader turned first vice president, expressed his dissatisfaction with Khartoum's policies in Darfur. Other political parties and newspapers also joined the dissent, arguing the regime had left it too late to activate its own justice system and demanding suspects be handed over to the ICC. The Popular Congress Party of Beshir's former mentor Hassan al-Turabi said the president had "missed the chance" earlier in the conflict to bring suspects to justice in Sudan. [...] The UN's former top envoy in Sudan, Jan Pronk, also stressed that Khartoum failed to seize the opportunity it was given to prove the efficiency and independence of its judiciary. "I told them in 2004 to come up with a credible legal process and they failed, this is a second chance," Pronk told AFP on the phone. "I am quite disappointed that the UN Security Council is not following up on its decisions... So I am pleased with the fact that the ICC prosecutor came out. It created a new political situation in Sudan. "I hope the president (Beshir) will be wise enough and make clear to his people that it's a non-political decision... If the regime came to that conclusion, it would also benefit itself," Pronk said. Darfur rebel groups unsurprisingly came out in favour of handing over suspects to The Hague, as did the Communist Party. "The government is fully responsible for what has happened and what is now happening in Darfur," the party said in a statement. Observers also suggested that Beshir's own National Congress Party may not speak in one voice on the issue. "The state of agitation inside the Congress is not surprising. The ICC is likely to come up with more names and some of the highest-ranking officials in the country could be on the list," a Western diplomat said. The cabinet postponed a meeting Sunday to allow for more political consultations before formulating its official response to the ICC." 3. Suna News Agency, "Sudan: Darfur militia leader to go on trial 7 March," 5 March 2007 (link not available) "Sudan news agency has learnt that three suspects will be arraigned in the special criminal court in Al-Junaynah court in the Delaij incidents in western Darfur State. The court proceedings will begin the day after tomorrow, Wednesday [7 March]. The accused are Ali Abd-al-Rahman Kushayb [suspected Janjawid militia leader and one of the suspects named by the International Criminal Court for crimes against humanity in Darfur], Hamdi Sharaf al-Din, and Add-al-Rahman Da'ud Humaydah. The proceedings will be chaired by High Court Judge Ahmad Abu Zayd and appeal court Judge Al-Sayuti Ibrahim and Fakhr-al-Din Hasan. The court will study reports presented to it by the special investigation committee that was investigating the Delaij incidents. The undersecretary at the ministry, Abd-al-Dayim Zamrawi, had said that suspects from the armed forces and popular defence forces would be arraigned before the special criminal court in Al-Junaynah." Other Related Articles: - Reuters, "Sudan to try suspect wanted by international court," 6 March 2007: http://www.alertnet.org/thenews/newsdesk/L06323237.htm - Agence France Presse, "Sudan to try Darfur suspect named by ICC," 6 March 2007: http://news.yahoo.com/s/afp/20070306/wl_africa_afp/sudandarfurunresticct rial_070306075036 - United Press International, "Sudan court to try Darfur suspects," 6 March 2007: http://www.upi.com/InternationalIntelligence/sudan_court_to_try_darfur_s uspects/20070306-105813-4798r/ **************************************************** B. KUSHAYB DENIES ICC CHARGES 1. Associated Press, Mohamed Osman, "Sudanese accused of war crimes in Darfur denies charges," 4 March 2007 http://www.iht.com/articles/ap/2007/03/04/africa/AF-GEN-Darfur-War-Crime s.php "A Sudanese accused of war crimes denied leading a group of janjaweed militias in attacks on civilians in Darfur, saying in a newspaper report Sunday that he had been recruited to protect villagers and nomads from the Arab militiamen. "We did not kill any innocent people and we did not cause the displacement of any people," Ali Mohammed Ali Abdal-Rahman, also known as Ali Kushayb, was quoted as saying in the pro-Arab, pro-Islamist Al Intibaha newspaper. He told Al Intibaha the accusations were untrue "simply because these acts never occurred in the first place." Kushayb accused "rebel elements" of setting him up to be accused of the alleged crimes. [...] Kushayb, who was dressed in a white turban and appeared to be in his mid-50s in the picture that accompanied Sunday's newspaper article, denied having met with Harun to carry out the alleged crimes. [...] ICC prosecutor Luis Moreno-Ocampo cited a rape victim in the town of Arawala who described in detail how Kushayb "personally inspected a group of naked women before they were raped by men under his command." In another incident, Kushayb, whom Moreno-Ocampo called a colonel of colonels in the janjaweed, "personally participated" in the summary execution of at least 32 men. Khartoum told Moreno-Ocampo that Kushayb was arrested last November and is in custody for investigation into five attacks in which hundreds of people were killed. The attacks were not the same as those being probed by the ICC, he said. [...]" **************************************************** C. PRESIDENT BASHIR REITERATES REJECTION OF ICC JURISDICTION 1. The Associated Press, Mohamed Osman, "Sudan president: No handover of citizens to international court over Darfur," 4 March 2007 http://www.iht.com/articles/ap/2007/03/03/africa/AF-GEN-Sudan-Darfur.php "President Omar al-Bashir on Saturday reiterated that Sudan will not hand over any Sudanese for trial abroad by international courts, such as the ICC which this week accused two Sudanese over Darfur atrocities. "(The) Sudanese judiciary is honest and qualified to try any Sudanese" who commit crimes against humanity, the president was quoted as saying by the official SUNA news agency during a visit to the Kordufan region, some 750 kilometers (470 miles) southwest of Khartoum. "The government will not hand over any citizen for trial outside the country," said al-Bashir. [...] Al-Bashir lashed out at those who "committed crimes against the Iraqi people, who are being killed, displaced and their infrastructure destroyed at the hands of the alliance forces" - a reference to U.S.-led troops in Iraq. Those perpetrators have "to be brought before courts of law and find prompt justice," al-Bashir said. In Sudan, "anyone who makes a mistake will be held responsible for it, but we are not going to take any dictates from abroad," the agency also quoted al-Bashir as saying. [...]" 2. Sudanese Radio (via BBC Monitoring), "Al-Bashir reiterates objection to trial of Darfur war criminals outside Sudan," 3 March 2007 (link not available) "[Presenter] The president of the republic, Umar Hasan al-Bashir has reiterated Sudan's objection to the trial of any Sudanese national outside the country. During a public rally at Umal Rahib village in Rashad locality, Southern Kordofan State, Al-Bashir told those behind the [International Criminal Court] ICC Prosecutor's decision on war crimes in Darfur, to turn their attention to crimes which are happening in Iraq, Palestine, Lebanon and Afghanistan against women and children. [...]" Other Related Articles - Reuters, "Bashir rejects trying citizens outside Sudan," 4 March 2007: http://www.reuters.com/article/homepageCrisis/idUSL04615521._CH_.2400 **************************************************** D. SUDANESE REACTIONS WELCOMING ICC ANNOUNCEMENT 1. The Times (London), Catherine Philp, "Man who terrorised Darfur clings on to safety in Sudan," 3 March 2007 http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/africa/article1464354.ece "Hawa Hassan can never forget the day she first clapped eyes on Ali Kushayb. [...] A man wearing mirrored sunglasses stepped out of his white 4x4. "Make them confess," he said. One of the men pulled his knife across her arm, a deep wound opened as she cried out and blood poured on to the sand. Mrs Hassan did not know it then, but the man was Ali Kushayb, the notorious Janjawid commander who led a wave of terror through the villages of western Darfur in 2003 and 2004, killing and driving out the non-Arab population. She had heard his name several times, in terrible accounts told by outsiders fleeing their burnt and pillaged villages. [...] This week, three years after that attack, Mrs Hassan heard Ali Kushayb's name again, on a radio in the sprawling refugee camp of Gaga. He had been named as a war crimes suspect by the International Criminal Court, along with a Sudanese minister, the first two to be named for atrocities in Darfur. "We were jubilant when we heard the news," said Bakar Qasab, 35, a survivor of the attack on the village of Bindis. "He killed and tortured many of our people." [...] "They do this for no other reason than that we are not Arabs," Mr Qasab said. "They want to commit genocide and to drive us all away." It was the testimony of refugees like these, in sunbaked camps along the Chad-Sudan border, that gave the court the ammunition to draw up the indictment against Ali Kushayb for 51 counts of crimes against humanity, including rape, torture and murder, in the villages around Bindis. [...] Of the two, his indictment is the most serious for Khartoum, formally linking the Janjawid's reign of terror to the Government -something that it continues to deny. The refugees have no doubt that Ali Kushayb was not his own man. Before he took up arms against them, many knew him as a soldier in the army, then a mercenary hired by Arab tribes to fight in local wars. "The Government recruited him and made him a Janjawid," said Abdullah Hassan Yusuf, who knew Ali Kushayb in Bindis. "When he went on his raids, the governor would even send sacks of sorghum to feed his horses. They were in it all together, all along." ICC officials say they hope that naming the two men may make others think twice about committing such crimes. The refugees are less hopeful. "I want to see them punished, but I am not optimistic they can be caught," Mrs Hassan said, fingering the scar on her arm. [...] "Justice is good. I would like that," Mrs Hassan said. "But mostly I want to go home."" 2. Reuters, Sean Maguire and Andrew Marshall, "INTERVIEW-Pressure Sudan and it will bow on Darfur - Turabi," 5 March 2007 http://www.alertnet.org/thenews/newsdesk/L05142367.htm "Foreign pressure, including the threat of international justice, will force Sudan to finally allow United Nations intervention in Darfur, leading opposition figure Hassan al-Turabi said on Monday. A military stalemate in Darfur, pressure from Sudan's southern politicians who share power in Khartoum and domestic political tensions will also drive the government of Omar al-Bashir to compromise, said Turabi. "They want to say 'yes' a little bit (on Darfur) and 'no' to handing over any minister" to an international court said the lawyer and politician who was the Islamic ideologue behind Bashir's rise in 1989 but gradually pushed out by the general. [...] Turabi said the government should cooperate with the ICC, which Sudan has said has no jurisdiction over its nationals. [...] "There is no justice here. Justice has to come from international courts, from outside," said the 75-year-old cleric, who was been jailed and placed under house arrest but has more latitude to criticise than less prominent opponents. [...]" 3. Al-Ra'y al-Amm (via BBC Monitoring), "Sudanese opposition urge state to cooperate with international court," 3 March 2007 (link not available) "The [opposition] National Ummah Party, which is led by Al-Sadiq al-Mahdi, has urged all the sides in the Darfur war and in particular the government, to cooperate with the international community and International Criminal Court [ICC] in the punishment of the perpetrators of criminal offences [in Darfur]. The party called for the formation of a truly national government to deal with the situation and reclaim the society's trust. In a statement, the party asked the government to "stop its excitable manner, political buffoonery, procrastination and outbidding that have tarnished the country's reputation, and instead sensibly accept the results of the investigations [into alleged Darfur war crimes] and take a sound legal position that will stand up to the case". In the same regard, the [opposition] Ummah Party for Reform and Renewal that is led by Mubarak al-Fadil, said the ICC in The Hague was the best place try the state minister for humanitarian affairs, Ahmad Harun, and the other suspect, Ali Kushayb [accused of war crimes in Darfur]. In a statement, the party said there were no examples under the Sudanese criminal law of the war crimes cases such as those The Hague court decides on." 4. United Press International, "Sudan communists: Give up suspects to ICC," 5 March 2007 http://www.upi.com/InternationalIntelligence/view.php?StoryID=20070305-0 14713-8606r "Sudan's opposition Communist Party urged the government to hand over to the International Criminal Court two officials suspected of war crimes in Darfur. A statement by the Sudanese Communist Party said Monday the government should cooperate with the ICC by surrendering the two officials and providing legal defense for them. [...] The communists said the naming of Sudanese officials was expected and the Khartoum government should have been legally and politically prepared, insisting the government bears full responsibility for the strife and escalation of the crisis in Darfur. "We have repeatedly demanded an investigation into the crimes committed in Darfur and to punish the perpetrators inside or outside the country, but the government doesn't listen to reason," the leftist group said. With this statement, the Communist Party has thus joined other major opposition Sudanese groups in supporting a call to hand over the two officials to the ICC for trial in The Hague." **************************************************** E. SUDANESE REJECTIONS OF ICC ALLEGATIONS AND JURISDICTION 1. Sudanese Media Centre (via BBC Monitoring), "Poll shows majority back refusal to hand over war crime suspects to court," 4 March 2007 (link not available) "Majority of respondents to a poll conducted by Al-Jazeera.net, have expressed support for Sudan's position not to transfer some of its citizens accused of committing war crimes in Darfur, western Sudan, to the International Criminal Court. Seventy-nine-point-six [79.6] per cent of the respondents in the poll, which has been running from 28 February, supported Khartoum's position not to hand over any Sudanese citizen to an international body outside the country. Some 20.4 per cent of those polled in the three-day survey in which 15,000 people took part, opposed the position of the Sudanese government to reject any trial of any Sudanese outside the country." 2. Al-Watan (via BBC Monitoring), "Sudanese tribe says it will not hand over Darfur war crime suspect," 4 March 2007 (link not available) "The Ta'aysha tribe of the suspect wanted by the International Criminal Court according to accusations made by Luis Moreno-Ocampo last week, Ali Kushayb, has rejected any talk about the possibility of handing him over to the international court. The nazir [paramount chief] of the Ta'aysha, Abd-al-Rahman Busharah Ali al-Sanusi, spoke to Al-Watan yesterday over the phone from the Nazarah's [tribal administration] HQ in Rihayd al-Bardi in the far south of west Darfur. The nazir said Kushayb is innocent of all 51 crimes he is suspected of committing and said he rejected Kushayb's trial even at a national court. "The tribe is completely confident that the government will not take the step of handing him over," Busharah added. He further said his tribe was not involved in the struggle in Darfur and questioned how a tribe that had supported the Mahdiyah [Mahdism - uprising against British colonialism] could engage in acts against humanity." 3. Al-Ra'y al-Amm (via BBC Monitoring), "Sudan's ruling party criticises supporters of Darfur crimes court," (link not available) "Presidential assistant and deputy leader of the [ruling] National Congress party [NC], Dr Nafi Ali Nafi has criticized political forces that announced their support for the trial of those accused of committing crimes in Darfur at the International Criminal Court [ICC], and described them of being ignorant. He further announced that anyone who evidence indicated was involved in criminal offences that violated the rights of individuals or groups would be tried, to be proven innocent or guilty stressing no one was above the law. Nafi denied the government was intending to put forward for trial in Sudan those whose names appear on the ICC list and said "this will not necessarily occur". However, he categorically stressed that the government would try anyone against whom there was conclusive evidence of committing violations whether they held constitutional or political positions because everyone, according to Nafi, is equal in the eyes of the law. Nafi further commended position of the leader of the Democratic Unionist Party, Muhammad Uthman al-Marghani, and revealed that Al-Marghani had contacted a number of NC leaders and reiterated his rejection to handing over any Sudanese citizen for trial outside the country. Nafi reiterated his strong criticism of political forces that announced their support for the ICC decision and said they were politically ignorant. He said by taking this stance these parties were committing political suicide and that their supporters would be given a reason to abandon them and join the national rank." 4. Suna News Agency, "Parliamantary Group in North Kordofan Describes ICC Decision as Illegal and Incorrect," 4 March 2007 "The Parliamentary Group of North Kordofan State has described the decision of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC) against two Sudanese national as illegal and incorrect. In a statement it issued Sunday, the Parliamentary Group regarded the accusations of the ICC as coming in the context of political pressures on Sudan government, threats for the interest of colonialists, and attempts to impose hegemony on the oppressed people.. The Parliamentary Group referred in this regard to the successive resolutions of the Security Council against Sudan, in a time when it is neglecting the violations which are taking place in Iraq, Bosnia-Herzegovina Palestine. The Parliamentary Group of North Kordofan State renewed its confidence on the Sudanese judiciary and justice." 5. Sudanese Media Center (via BBC Monitoring), "Darfur lawyers denounce international court's war crimes summon," 3 March 2007 (link not available) "Lawyers from Darfur have strongly condemned the accusations made by the prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC) against Sudanese citizens [Ahmad Muhammad Harun and Ali Muhammad Ali Abdal-Rahman, also known as Kushayb]. In a statement issued today, the lawyers said the decision by the ICC's Prosecutor is not backed by any legal basis as Sudan is not a signatory to the statute of the international court thus, is not a party to the agreement and can not oblige by the decisions made by it. The statement added that those doubting the Sudanese judicial system and demanding an international trial on the country's matters only represents a foreign agenda at the nation. The statement issued by the Darfur Lawyers Association said they are the ones who have been affected the most by the crisis." 6. Suna News Agency, "Legal Expert: Decision of ICC Prosecutor is political one," 3 March 2007 (link not available) "Legal Expert Dr. Khalid Hussein Mohamed has affirmed that the recent decision of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC) is considered as a political decision, adding that it came within the context of the foreign targeting to the country. Speaking at a symposium on "the Decision of ICC between the Law and Politics" which was organized at Al-Zubair Hall here Saturday, Dr. Khalid said that Sudan has fulfilled many of its regional and international obligations towards the peace process, adding that unfortunately the international community did not meet its pledges to support peace in the country. He added that Sudan, instead, was punished by not lifting its name from the so-called list of states harboring terrorism besides triggering sedition in Darfur as well as issuance of resolution 1706 on deployment of international troops in Darfur. Dr. Mohamed asserted that the ICC statute prevents its interference in any armed conflicts in countries. Professor at Omdurman Islamic University Dr. Abdel-Latif Al-Bony said that the ICC decision would not contribute to boosting of the efforts being exerted to realize peace and stability in Darfur, adding that the decision instead will distract the attention from the basic issue to other matters not serve Sudan and issues of its people." 7. Suna News Agency, "Haj Musa Says Sudan to Encounter The Hague Declaration," 2 March 2007 (link not available) "Head of Legislation and Legal Affairs Committee at the Council of States Dr. Ismail Al-Haj Musa affirmed that Sudan will work for reactivation of the International Criminal Court Statute which says the Court shall be complementary to the national criminal jurisdictions. Speaking at SUNA Regular Press Forum on Thursday on violations of UN missions around the World, Haj Musa stated that Sudan does not want to clash with international community but at the same time does not want to submit to its all resolutions, especially, he explained, when they do not conform with norms and international conventions. [...]" **************************************************** F. EUROPEAN UNION COUNCIL CONCLUSIONS 1. European Union, Council Conclusions on Sudan/Darfur - 2789th EXTERNAL RELATIONS Council Meeting, Brussels, 5 March 2007: http://www.consilium.europa.eu/cms3_applications/Applications/newsRoom/L oadDocument.asp?directory=en/gena/&filename=93080.pdf "[...] The Council takes note of the presentation by the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC) of evidence of war crimes and crimes against humanity in Darfur, as a result of the investigation mandated by UN Security Council Resolution 1593 (2005), and welcomes it as a decisive step to put an end to impunity in Darfur. Reaffirming its support for the ICC, the Council expects the Sudanese Government to cooperate fully with the Court. [...]" 2. Associated Press (via International Herald Tribune), Paul Ames, "EU appeals for international help to finance Darfur peacekeeping," 5 March 2007 http://www.iht.com/articles/ap/2007/03/05/europe/EU-GEN-EU-Sudan.php "European Union foreign ministers appealed Monday for wider international help to pay for the African peacekeeping force in Darfur as the EU struggles to maintain its own funding for the mission. In a statement, the EU said it was imperative to "urgently address the funding need" and appealed to international donors to "contribute to the success of the mission." [...] The EU also called on Sudan to cooperate fully with the International Criminal Court which last week accused a junior Cabinet minister and a member of the Sudanese security forces of war crimes and crimes against humanity for atrocities in Darfur. Al-Bashir on Saturday insisted Sudan will not hand over its citizens for trial abroad by international courts." **************************************************** G. OTHER INTERNATIONAL REACTIONS 1. MENA News Agency (Egypt) (via BBC Monitoring), "Egyptian president briefed on developments by Sudanese leader's aide," 5 March 2007 "President Husni Mubarak received on Monday [5 March] a message from Sudanese President Umar Hasan Bashir on developments in Sudan and the outcome of the four-way summit held in Tripoli on Darfur and Sudan's relations with Chad. [...] Whether he discussed with Mubarak Sudan's rejection to hand over any Sudanese official to the International Criminal Court, Ismail said he explained to Mubarak the development of this issue and the strategy of the Sudanese government which is based on addressing the Darfur conflict, reaching a political solution with the non-signatory parties to Abuja agreement and bringing about security in Darfur. He made it clear that everything either the court or any other issue is a repercussion of the Darfur problem. The adviser said the Sudanese government formed committees to find means to face the development of the international court's decision." 2. Suna News Agency, "Malaysian Foreign Minister Describes ICC Prosecutor's Decision against Sudan as Political, Illegal and Unjustifiable," 4 March 2007 (link not available) "The Malaysian Foreign Minister, Sayed Hamid Al-Bar, has described unjustifiable, political and illegal the decision of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC) on accusations of humanitarian crimes against a number of Sudanese citizens. Interviewed by SUNA in the Syrian capital, Damascus, the Malaysian minister said that the Sudanese judicial system is capable to hold trial of any person who is accused of violation of the International and humanitarian Laws. He said that the International Criminal Court (ICC) has no jurisdiction to hold trial for any Sudanese national. [...]" 3. Suna News Agency, "Wide indignation amid trends concerned with Sudanese matter in towards ICC Prosecutor report," 3 March 2007 (link not available) "Many trends among those concerned with the Sudanese situation in the United Kingdom have received the decision of the International Criminal Court (ICC) Prosecutor on trial of Sudanese subjects outside their homeland with great indignation, whereas many politicians, journalists and university lecturers, interviewed by SUNA, have denounced the report and the scenario with which it was presented. Many of them wondered about the legitimacy of the Court and how binding its decisions would be for the Sudan. Others wondered about the neutrality and fairness of the report as it neglected the other party to the conflict, the armed movements. Some described the report as serving the movements and present them a moral does through regarding them as innocents. The prominent leader in the British Conservative Party Donald Stewart, speaking to SUNA, said that the decision, as it is, does not, in any way, contribute to peace making in Darfur, but rather leads to an opposite result, adding that the decision not unbalanced. Researcher in the British Parliament and present writer on Sudanese affairs, Dr. David Charles, told SUNA that in the case of World War II the trials were held after the war ended a matter, which is not the case in Darfur now, and therefore before talking about trials, the war should be stopped and peace be achieved, then afterwards a neutral mechanism, to be agreed upon by the international community, be provided to make investigations based on which fair trials would be held and supported by the International Community and the regional organizations involved in the peace process. Ex-lecturer at London University Al-Rasheed Mohamed Khair said that the decision is unbalanced and lacks professionalism and neutrality, because it has clearly neglected the other party to the conflict and mentioned nothing of the movements and the horrors, bypassing those attributed to others, committed by their militias. He added that everybody, according to the reports of the international organizations that visited the region, is aware of what had been committed by these militias that even worse that the accessions raised against others. Ahmed Wiqwaialla, a businessman living in London, said the report is clearly biased in favors of the rebel movements and that the American prospect neglects the other party and provides them with a great moral boost by condemning a party at the cost of the others. He added that the international community should practice pressures to achieve peace first then search for trials, which are to boost peace and not trigger the war." **************************************************** CICC'S POLICY ON THE REFERRAL AND PROSECUTION OF SITUATIONS BEFORE THE ICC: The Coalition for the ICC is not an organ of the Court. The CICC is an independent NGO movement dedicated to the establishment of the International Criminal Court as a fair, effective, and independent international organization. The Coalition will continue to provide the most up-to-date information about the ICC and to help coordinate global action to effectively implement the Rome Statute of the ICC. The Coalition will also endeavor to respond to basic queries and to raise awareness about the ICC's trigger mechanisms and procedures, as they develop. The Coalition as a whole, and its secretariat, do not endorse or promote specific investigations or prosecutions or take a position on situations before the ICC. However, individual CICC members may endorse referrals, provide legal and other support on investigations, or develop partnerships with local and other organizations in the course of their efforts. Communications to the ICC can be sent to: ICC P.O. Box 19519 2500 CM The Hague The Netherlands |
|
|